Comment-Analysis I
Posted by: Marcel in Astrology and Esoteric, Comment-Analysis, Physics
As I am already talking about comments in the last blog post, I can as well start a new category now: comment analysis. I regularly get comments on my critical post concerning esoteric and the misuse of quantum-physics for their purposes. Those comments are often, well, ‘interesting’. I am going to analyze one in the following. Maybe at some point in time I will have collected enough of them to compare and find common features.
Today’s comment is by someone calling himself ‘Art. 4 GG’. This is the first observation: These type of comments are often anonymous. It was posted at a followup of a followup (what’s next, followup cubed?) of a article criticizing a esoteric event stating that quantum-physics would support their believes. As most of these comments, it is in German. Another interesting point.
It starts with quoting a former German judge, in a typical manner of referring to ‘authorities’ in support of one owns point of view. I am actually immune to it: Not the opinions of some people count (even famous people do make errors and might have strange believes). What is important are the arguments.
By the way: the quote by said former judge, Martin Kriele, is critisized here (in German), he reacts to this in a very impolite manner on his homepage, personally attacking the lifestyle of the critic. He signed a declaration which supports the view that you could ‘heal’ homosexuality. His Wife, Alexa Kriele, works as an ‘Angel-Interpreter’, has been in the German TV recently (a good criticizing article can be found here, in German). Her husband supports her, was involved in her books on angles and their healing powers and wrote a foreword. Now I should take this guy seriously?
The comment goes on in a very rude manner, attacking me and my mental capabilities. There are no arguments or supporting evidence why I should be wrong. Instead, he says:
Your critical comments are undecided, blatantly unsubstantiated and confirm your self-assessment that quantum physics is hard to understand for you, because obviously you are uninformed, or de facto intellectually unable to grasp the findings of quantum physics.
In short, less complicated words: “You have no idea or are stupid.” I am not sure what is the best way to treat these kinds of comments: simply ignore and delete them, or allow them to appear as they unmask the was esoterics think and argue? I decided for the latter here. Especially, because the commenter does not have any clue about who I am: I studied Physics for several years, my professor in theoretical physics must have been of other opinion about my capabilities than the commenter as I got my degree recently, and now I am doing my PhD. Furthermore, I even studied the influences of quantum physics on philosophy in my minor. I would say I know enough about the topic.
Tags: AGPF, Alexa Kriele, Maischberger, Marburger Erklärung, Martin Kriele, Angel-Interpreter, Angels, Astrology and Esoteric, Comments, Philosophy, Physics, Quantum-Philosophy and Spirituality, Quantum-Philosophy, Quantum-Physics, Spirituality, TV

















Entries (RSS)